Home Cookin' with Tom Valenti Upstate and outside with the talented executive chef of Ouest and 'Cesca
ByJJ Goode Photography by Bryan Drago
In beat-up moccasins, jeans, and a flannel button-up, clutching a handful of chives from his garden, Tom Valenti strides toward a patch of wild mint, steps from the door of his modest cabin in Delaware County, New York. “I think it’s chocolate mint or spearmint,” he says, grabbing a bunch of the round, purple-tinged leaves.
His cabin, on the wooded bank of the Beaverkill River, is his sanctuary, only about two and a half hours from his New York City apartment—and his two busy restaurants, Ouest and 'Cesca. “I come up here every weekend in the summer,” Valenti says. “It’s how I stay sane.” His upstate cooking strategy is the antidote to his hectic life in the city, where he spends most waking hours in clangorous, overheated kitchens. Here, he says, “I just throw everything on the grill.”
Often, he grills vegetables that he has marinated briefly in olive oil and lemon juice, dumping them back in the marinade as soon as they’ve charred and sweetened. Minimally adorned meat, fish, or fowl joins them on the grill and shares the table with good cheese and salad. For dessert, he might amble up his steep, rocky driveway to the nearby road to pick wild strawberries and eat them plain or in light syrup made from lemon juice, water, sugar, and wild pineapple sage. Otherwise, he breaks out pints of Häagen Dazs.
As Valenti wanders his six acres, he’s prone to spontaneous exclamations of joy—“Wow!”—as if it were his first time seeing the poplars, oaks, cherries, and maples
tilting toward the sleepy Beaverkill. An avid fly fisherman, he first saw the cabin in April 14 years ago, and loved its location on the trout-heavy river. (He is vehemently opposed to eating wild trout; anything he catches is immediately placed back in the water, nose into the current. Valenti recommends Edenbrook Farm–raised trout, which is available at Union Square Greenmarket.) He bought it despite the fact that the grounds were more or less barren. That May, however, brought a surprise fit for a chef: his yard exploded with vegetation, a lot of it edible. Ramps, watercress, and pineapple sage had sprung up on his lawn; tightly curled fiddlehead ferns and cattails had grown near the riverbank. Cattails are edible? “Oh, yeah!” he says. “Just strip the base of the stalk; they taste like a cross between asparagus and salsify.”
Chanterelles, morels, and other wild mushrooms grow abundantly nearby, on a small island downriver, where Valenti and his wife, Abigail, were married five years ago. To reach it, they donned chest-high fishing waders and slogged through the water, along with two witnesses and a justice of the peace. Abigail did not wear a wedding dress. “It would’ve been hard to fit a train in waders,” he says, laughing.
Eighteen years before Valenti changed the state of dining on the Upper West Side by opening Ouest, in 2001, he was in Charles de Gaulle airport, heading back to New York, having just finished a cooking stint with renowned French chef Guy Savoy. By coincidence, he bumped into Alfred Portale, who was also returning to New York after cooking in Roanne, France, with the famous Troisgros brothers. They hit it off, and Portale made Valenti his first sous chef at Gotham Bar and Grill, where Portale was taking a job as executive chef. After 2 years there, Valenti moved between different executive-chef positions, generating good reviews as he went, notably at the cult classic Allison on Dominick and Butterfield 81. (Both have since closed.)
In early 2000, Valenti was approached by an old acquaintance who wanted to open a restaurant on the Upper West Side—at the time uncharted territory for serious restaurants. He sensed the neighborhood was ripe, and soon his French-inspired American cooking had a proper platform—and the crowds ate bacon-wrapped meatloaf and braised lamb shank. 2½ years later, he followed up with ‘Cesca, where creating the Italian-inspired American menu conjured-up memories of Valenti’s childhood. It was his Neapolitan grandmother who had sparked his interest in cooking when he was a child. His family had little money, and young Valenti looked on as his grandmother made magnificence from humble cuts of meat. “I don’t remember her anywhere other than at the table or in the kitchen,” Valenti says. ‘Cesca was for her.
Sharing one of his cabin’s three small rooms is a kitchen. There is no counter space; a diminutive old-school gas oven is packed with Tupperware and assorted kitchen utensils. His working upstate kitchen is not inside the cabin but outside on the deck, overlooking the river—a small green Aussie Grill. “I just liked it because it was a pretty color,” he jokes, understanding my surprise that a chef who loves to grill would lack a stainless-steel monster. “It’s the same mechanism,” he added. “You don’t need the bells and whistles when you’re surrounded by them all week long.”
For me, bells and whistles sounded when Valenti brought out Edenbrook Farm trout stuffed with breadcrumbs, garlic, herbs, and butter, and wrapped in thin slices of bacon. I listened to the sizzle as they hit the hot grate. He had prepared them for the grill the night before, as is his modus operandi when entertaining. “When I have a few cocktails and I’m hungry, I don’t feel like cooking,” Valenti says. Asparagus, corn, portabellos, and red peppers were on and off the grill quickly, and he tended to a salad of new potatoes he had boiled the night before. He doused them with olive oil and scattered salt and pepper. His handful of garden chives was destined for this salad; he tore them into two or three pieces and tossed them in a big bowl with the potatoes. The delicate leaves of wild mint were embellishment for a summer berry cobbler.
Soon, lunch was ready, and I was cracking the trout’s frail armor and digging in to its moist flesh. We were on the deck, and Valenti was looking out toward the water, naming birds as they flew by and soared overheard. His phone rang: a friend trying to plan a day of fly-fishing. Clearly, he was not thinking about his restaurants—a testament to a terrific support staff. “They used to call me a lot, but then I took the phone off the hook.”
Tom’s Home Cookin’ Tips
Must-haves for the cupboard
Beer (he likes Bud or Tecate up at the cabin), good extra-virgin olive oil such as the Greek Iliada, Baleine French sea salt, fresh ground pepper, Dijon mustard, Hellman's mayonnaise, garlic, and pickled fiddlehead ferns and ramps, which he usually gets from a friend up the road. (“They make it well with stuff they pick on their property.”)
When entertaining
“If I can get 80 percent of the meal prepped and ready to go [beforehand], I’m happy.” Valenti says that braises and stews are great to prepare ahead of time; in fact, he says, they are better after a day or two in the fridge. Just heat them up when you’re ready to eat. He also likes to blanch vegetables in advance of their use in recipes later on. Good trick: Marinate vegetables for a short time in olive oil and vinegar or lemon—the acid wakes up the palate. Then throw them on the grill, reserving the marinade. After the vegetables are done, put them back in the marinade and serve.
Favorite Farmers
Edenbrook Farm for trout, and Mountain Sweet Berry Farm, where his farmer friend Rick Bishop lives, just 10 minutes away. “His stuff is great. [Last week] he was showing me some sprouts—he’s starting to grow some Italian bean varieties for Cesare Casella at Beppe.” Occasionally he’ll hit the farmers’ markets in Roscoe or Walton. “Once [my wife and I] get up here, we plant and sit. Sometimes we won’t get in the car for three days.”